Critical Review of Construction Accident Causation Theories and Models: The Need for Improved Models

Author/s

Opeyemi Samuel Williams

Department of Quantity Surveying, Faculty of Built Environment and Surveying, Universiti Teknologi Malaysia, 81310 UTM Johor Bahru, Johor, Malaysia, And Department of Quantity Surveying, Faculty of Environmental Studies, Rufus Giwa Polytechnic, Owo, Ondo State, Nigeria.

Razali Adul Hamid

Department of Quantity Surveying, Faculty of Built Environment and Surveying, Universiti Teknologi Malaysia, 81310 UTM Johor Bahru, Johor, Malaysia 

Mohd Saidin Misnan

Department of Quantity Surveying, Faculty of Built Environment and Surveying, Universiti Teknologi Malaysia, 81310 UTM Johor Bahru, Johor, Malaysia.

 

Abstract

Construction industry is recognized and best described as an accident-prone industry, being characterized with a plethora of occupational risks. Review of literature on construction accidents revealed that a copious number of theories have been propounded over the years by different theorists, though some of these theories were criticized. In addition to this were the multifarious models developed by different proponents at different times. However, accidents are an unplanned event that are common on the building construction sites, involving materials, objects and people with attendant damages, loses and injuries. Moreover, existing models were developed to investigate the causations of accident with the aim of preventing its occurrence. Effort to analyze the existing models, with criticism in view, was the aim of this research, which was accomplished by pointing out the limitations of applicability of the models and ascertaining the need for an improved model. A major gap was discovered, in that most of these models concentrated on accident causations and investigations with little or no emphasis on preventive measures via the duties of the construction stakeholders (client, consultant, contractor, health and safety agency) at the preconstruction and during construction stages. Having considered the strengths and weaknesses of the existing models, it was discovered that another, but improved, model was needed and such model will consequently enable construction stakeholders in putting up and implementing accident preventive measures on the building construction sites, as all stakeholders have significant roles to play in preventing accident.

Keywords

Accident theory, Construction Accident, Accident Causation Model, Accident Prevention.

 

To cite this article

Williams, O.S., Hamid, R.A., & Misnan, M.S. (2019). Critical Review of Construction Accident Causation Theories and Models: The Need for Improved Models, International Journal of Engineering, IT and Scientific Research (IJEISR). Vol. 3, No. 2, pp.23-39. Doi:10.31219/osf.io/9gwsy

Copyright

Copyright © 2019 Authors retain the copyright of this article.
This article is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/) which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.

References

Abdelhamid T.S. and Everett, A. (2000). Identifying Root Causes of Construction Accident. Journal of Construction Engineering and Management, 126:(1)pp. 1–9.

Abdul Hamid, A.R., Abdul Majid, M.Z. and Singh, B. (2008). Causes of Accidents at Construction Sites. Malaysian Journal of Civil Engineering, 20(2): pp. 242-259.

Abubakar U. (2015). An Overview of the Occupational Safety and Health Systems of Nigeria, UK, USA, Australia and China: Nigeria Being the Reference Case Study. American Journal of Educational Research, 2015, Vol. 3, No. 11, pp. 1350-1358.

Adams, E. (1976). Accident Causation and the Management Systems. Professional Safety, Vol. 21 No10, pp. 26-29.

Agwu, M. O. and Olele, H. E. (2014). Fatalities in the Nigerian Construction Industry : A Case of Poor Safety Culture. British Journal of Economics, Management & Trade, 4(3), pp. 431–452.

Al-Tabtabai, H. M. (2002). Analyzing Construction Site Accidents in Kuwait. Kuwait Journal of Science and Engineering, 29(2), pp. 213–238.

Ale, B.J.M. (2006). The Occupational Risk Model. Final Report of the Workgroup on ORM. Technical University Delft, The Netherlands.

Ale B.J.M., Bellamy L.J., Baksteen H., Damen M., Goossens L.H.J, Hale A.R, Mud M., Oh J., Papazoglou I.A. and Whiston J.Y. (2007). Accidents in the Construction Industry in the Netherlands: An analysis of Accident Reports Using Storybuilder. Reliability Engineering and System Safety, 93 (2008) pp. 1523-1533

Asan, A. and Akasah, Z. A. (2015). Developing an Accident Causation Model for Accident Prevention at Building Construction Sites. Springer Science+Business Media Singapore, pp. 273–285.

Bellamy, L. J., Ale, B. J. M., Geyer, T. A. W., Goossens, L. H. J., Hale, A. R., Oh, J., … Whiston, J. Y. (2007). Storybuilder-A Tool for the Analysis of Accident Reports. Reliability Engineering and System Safegty, 92(6), 735–744.

Bird, F. (1974). Management Guide to Loss Control. International Safety Academy, Houston.

Brown, K. A., Willis, P. G., & Prussia, G. E. (2000). Predicting Safe Employee Behaviour in the Steel Industry: Development and Test of a Sociotechnical Model. Journal of Operations Management, 18, pp. 445–465.

Choudhry, R. M. and Fang, D. 2008. Why Operatives Engage in Unsafe Work Behaviour: Investigating Factors on Construction Sites. Safety Science, 46(4): pp. 566–584.

Diugwu, I. A., Baba, D. L. and Egila, A. E. (2012). Effective Regulation and Level of Awareness: An Exposé of the Nigeria’s Construction Industry. Open Journal of Safety Science and Technology, 2012, (2), pp. 140-146 doi:10.4236/ojsst.2012.24018.

Douglas H. and Crowe (1976). Effective Loss Prevention. Industrial Accident Prevention assoc., Toronto

Edwards, D. J. and Nicholas, J. (2002). The State of Health and Safety in the UK Construction Industry with a Focus on Plant Operators. Structural Survey, Vol. 20 Iss 2, pp. 78–87.

Ehi I. (2010). The Absence of Occupational Health and Safety Laws in Nigeria. Occupational Health and Safety Managers (Nigeria). Available on-line @ http://ohsmcomng.blogspot.my. Accessed on 17 Jan, 2017

Eurocontrol Experimental Centre (2006). Revisiting the Swiss Cheese Model of Accidents. Project Safbuild – EEC Note No. 13/06.

Ezenwa, A. O. (2001). A Study of Fatal Injuries in Nigerian Factories. Occupational Medicine, 51(8), pp. 485–489. https://doi.org/10.1093/occmed/51.8.485

Goh, K. C., Goh, H. H., Omar, M. F., Toh, T. C. and Asuhaimi, A. (2016). Accidents Preventive Practice for High-Rise Construction. In MATEC Web of Conferences, 47(August), 3–8. https://doi.org/10.1051/matecconf/20164704004

Hale, A. R., Ale, B. J M., Goossens, L. H J., Heijer, T., Bellamy, L. J., Mud, M. L., Roelen, A., Baksteen, H., Post, J., Papazoglou, I. A., Bloemhoff, A. and Oh, J. I H. (2007). Modeling Accidents for Prioritizing Prevention. Reliability Engineering and System Safety 92 (2007), pp. 1701–1715

HaSPA (Health and Safety Professionals Alliance) (2012). The Core Body of Knowledge for Generalist OHS Professionals. Tullamarine, VIC. Safety Institute of Australia.

Heinrich, H.W. (1931). Industrial Accident Prevention: A Scientific Approach, McGraw-Hill, New York.

Heinrich, H.W. (1969). Industrial Accident Prevention, 4th Ed.,McGraw- Hill, New York.

Holt A.S.J., (2006). Principles of Health and Safety at Work, 1st Edition Publishing, Technology & Engineering.

Hosseinian, S. S., & Torghabeh, Z. J. (2012). Major Theories of Construction Accident Causation Models : A Literature Review. International Journal of Advances in Engineering & Techonology, 4(2), pp. 53–66.

Hovden, J., Abrechtsen, E. and Herrera, I. A. (2010). Is There a Need for New Theories, Models and Approaches to Occupational Accident Prevention? Safety Science, 48(8), pp. 950-956.

Health and Safety Executive (HSE) (2006). Health and Safety in Construction. Health and Safety in Construction HSG150, 141.  Retrieved from http://www.hse.gov.uk/pubns/priced/hsg150.pdf

Idoro, G. I. (2008). Health and Safety Management Efforts as Correlates of Performance in the Nigerian Construction Industry. Journal of Civil Engineering and Management, pp. 277–285. ISSN 1392-3730,

Idoro, G. I. (2011). Comparing Occupational Health and Safety (OHS) Management Efforts and Performance of Nigerian Construction Contractors. Journal of Construction in Developing Countries, 16(2), pp. 151–173

Ikpe, E. O. (2009). Development of Cost Benefit Analysis Model of Accident Prevention on     Construction Projects. Postgraduate Thesis, University of Wolverhampton.

Johnson, A. (2011). Examining the Foundation: Were Heinrich’s Theories Valid, and do they Still Matter? Health and Safety Magazine.

Jocelyn S., Chinniah Y., Ouali, M-S. and Yacout S. (2016). Application of Logical Analysis of Data to Machinery-Related Accident Prevention Based on Scarce Data, Reliability Engineering and System Safety 159 (2017), pp. 223-236.

Kadiri Z.O., Nden T., Avre G.K., Oladipo T.O., Edom A., Samuel P.O. and Ananso G.N. (2014). Causes and Effects of Accidents on Construction Sites (A Case Study of Some Selected Construction Firms in Abuja F.C.T Nigeria). IOSR Journal of Mechanical and Civil Engineering (IOSR-JMCE) e-ISSN: 2278-1684, -ISSN: 2320-334X, Volume 11, Issue 5 Ver. I. pp. 66-72.

Kerr, W. (1957). Complementary Theories of Safety Psychology. Journal of. Social Psychology, 45, pp. 3-9

Kolo, D. N. (2015). Safety Issues Involving Workers on Building Construction Sites in Nigeria : An Abuja Study. Postgraduate Thesis, Eastern Mediterranean University,Gazimağusa, North Cyprus.

Loosemore M, (1998). Psychology of Accident Prevention in the Construction Industry. Journal of Management in Engineering, 14(3): pp. 50-56.

Mitropoulos, P., Abdelhamid, T. S. and Howell, G. A. (2005). Systems Model of Construction Accident Causation. Journal of Construction Engineering and Management. https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)0733-9364(2005)131

Nkem, A. N., Hassim, M. H. and Kidam, K. (2015). Relationship Between Unsafe Acts/ Condition and Accidents in Construction Company in Nigeria. Jurnal Teknologi (Sciences & Engineering) 75:6, pp. 73–77.

Nkurunungi, W. J., (2005). Assessment of Safety of Workers at Building Sites in Uganda. Undergraduate Thesis, Makerere University

Okoye, P. and Okolie, K.  (2014). Exploratory Study of the Cost of Health and Safety Performance of Building Contractors in South- East Nigeria. British Journal of Environmental Sciences, 2(1), pp. 21–33.

Oladiran, O. J., Ogunsanmi, O. E. and Soyingbe, A. A. (2008). Control Measures of Accident: Nigerian Building Projects’ Case. Proceedings of CIB-2008-Transformation through Construction, 15-17 November, Dubai., (2005), 10.

Orji Solomon E., Enebe Eucharia, C. and Onoh. Felix. E. (2016). Accidents in Building Construction Sites in Nigeria: A Case of Enugu State. International Journal of Innovative Research and Development, 5(4), pp. 244–248.

Orji Solomon E., Nwachukwu Lilian N. and Enebe Eucharia .C (2016). Hazards in Building Construction Sites and Safety Precautions in Enugu Metropolis , Enugu State. Imperial Journal of Interdisciplinary Research (IJIR), 2(1), pp. 282–289.

Pereira, E., Taghaddos, H., Hermann, R., Han, S. and Abourizk, S. (2015). A Conceptual Accident Causation Model Based on the Incident Root Causes. 5th International/11th Construction Specialty Conference 5e International/11e Conférence spécialisée sur la construction.

Petersen, D. (1971). Techniques of Safety Management. McGraw-Hill, New York.

Pillay, K. R. (2014). The Costs of Construction Accidents. Postgraduate Thesis, Cape Peninsula University of Technology.

Reason, J. (1990). The Contribution of Latent Human Failures to the Breakdown of Complex Systems. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society (London), Series B. 327: pp. 475-484.

Sabet, P. G.P., Aadal H., Jamshidi, M.H.M. and Rad, G.K. (2013). Application of Domino Theory to Justify and Prevent Accident Occurrence in Construction Sites. IOSR Journal of Mechanical and Civil Engineering (IOSR-JMCE). Volume 6, Issue 2, pp. 72-76.

Steensma J. T. (2010). Transformational Leadership and Safety in Steel Mills : A Quantitative Study in a High Hazard Environment. Postgraduate Dissertation, Faculty Division of Graduate Studies in Leadership and the College of Graduate Studies.

Suraji, A., Duff, A.R., and Peckitt, S. (2001). Development of Causal Model of Construction Accident Causation. Journal of Construction Engineering and Management /127(4), pp. 337–344.

Udo, U. E., Usip, E. E. and Asuquo, C. F. (2016). Effect of Lack of Adequate Attention to Safety Measures on Construction Sites in Akwa Ibom State , Nigeria, Journal of Earth Sciences and Geotechnical Engineering, Vol. 6, No.1, pp. 113-121 ISSN: 1792-9040 (print), 1792-9660 (online) Scienpress Ltd.

Umeokafor N., Evaggelinos K., Lundy S., Isaac D., Allan S., Igwegbe O., Umeokafor K. and Umeadi B. (2014). The Pattern of Occupational Accidents, Injuries, Accident Causal Factors and Intervention in Nigerian Factories. Developing Country Studies, ISSN 2224-607X (Paper) ISSN 2225-0565 (Online) Vol.4, No.15.

Weaver, D. (1971) Symptoms of Operational Error. Professional Safety, Oct (ASSE)

Weeks, J. L. (2011). Health and Safety Hazards in the Construction Industry. Encyclopedia of Occupational Health and Safety. Available on-line @ https://www.scribd.com/document/207967526/

Williams, O. S., Hamid, A.R. and Misnan, M.S. (2017). Analysis of Fatal Building Construction Accidents: Cases and Causes. Journal of Multidisciplinary Engineering Science and Technology (JMEST) ISSN: 2458-9403 Vol. 4 Issue 8, pp. 8030-8040.

Williams, O. S., Hamid, A.R. and Misnan, M.S. (2018). Accident Causal Factors on the Building Construction Sites: A Review. International Journal of Built Environment and Sustainability, 5(1), pp. 78-92.

Williams, O. S., Hamid A.R. and Misnan M.S (2019). Causes of Building Construction Related Accident in the South-Western States of Nigeria. International Journal of Built Environment and Sustainability, 6(1), pp. 14-22.